Showing posts with label Murder-Coaching Moms. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Murder-Coaching Moms. Show all posts

Saturday, July 26, 2014

Judith Hawkey, Murder-Coaching Mom – Ohio, 2003


FULL TEXT: Defiance, Ohio – Defiance County Judge Joseph Schmenk handed down the highest sentence possible in the case of Judith Hawkey, life without the possibility or parole.

On November 3, 2003, Hawkey's step-son, Corey Breninger shot and killed his father Robert Breninger at his Mark Center, Ohio, home. At the time, it was ruled an accident.

The son revealed years later to a teacher after Hawkey had collected hundreds of thousands in life insurance from Robert. He said Hawkey had manipulated him to pull the trigger, and then lie about what happened.

Corey, now 20, addressed Hawkey in court.

"The pain you have put me through should send you straight to hell," said Corey Breninger.

During sentencing, the judge took long pauses trying to find the right words, calling the case unique to him.

He made scathing remarks describing Hawkey, including manipulative, and "evil beyond description."

Hawkey, who court witnesses said showed no remorse for her actions, denies her guilt.

Hawkey said, "He [Corey] shot his father purposely, and made up this whole story."

Evidence convinced the jury that she was entirely to blame.

After the sentencing, Corey spoke with reporters about the his feelings saying, "Relief. I feel like she got what she deserved. I was ready to get it off my chest. I was bearing that burden for so many years."

Corey says now he can get on with his life.

"[I can] stop living in the shadows. I don't have to worry about anything now. My biggest fear... she's gone," said Breninger.

Corey plans to use his difficult experience to help others, who may have endured similar abuses.

[Chris Delcamp, Woman who manipulated 10-year-old to kill his father gets life without parole,” Dec. 19, 2013]

***


***

For similar cases, see Murder-Coaching Moms

***

Sunday, June 1, 2014

Murder-Coaching Moms


Following are 35 cases in which mothers coaxed or ordered their own children to commit murder.

***

1740 – Elizabeth Branch – Taunton, Somerset, England

Elizabeth Branch and her daughter Mary were executed for the murder of a 13-year-old servant girl. They had tortured this and other victims in their employ mercilessly. One boy was tortured until he soiled himself and was then forced to eat his own excrement. It was suspected that Mrs. Branch has murdered her husband and her own mother and another servant girl.

***


While her husband was eating, Roxalana Druse “stole up behind him and shot him. The daughter Mary, who had been provided with a rope noose, then appeared upon the scene, threw the cord about him and dragged him to the floor. Mrs. Druse then called Frank Grates back into the house. Handing the boy the pistol, she said it would not go off, and ordered him to shoot her husband or himself be shot. The deed commanded seemed more desirable to the youngster than its alternative, and he commenced the work with trembling alacrity. But before he had emptied all the chambers of the revolver the infuriated female tore the pistol from his hand and finished the horrid task herself. Then with an ax she cut off the dying man's head, dismembered the body and chopped it small enough to burn and boil, the boys gathering shingles to make right hot fires in both stoves. All this with the assistance of her daughter Mary and in the presence of her little son George. Then she fell into the errors that finally led to her detection. The fragments of the body were thrown into the boiler and two red-hot stoves.”

***


Sexually tortured and murdered 3 orphan girls. Her son’s participation was not clear, but he was at least a passive participant.

***

1897 – Nancy Staffleback – Galena, Kansas – Leader of a murderous clan guilty of at least 6 murders; 2 sons convicted along with their mother.
“George and Ed Staffleback have been found guilty of murder in the first degree and sentenced to the penitentiary for life, while the mother, hoary in crime as in years – she is now 65 – has been found guilty of murder in the second degree and will no doubt end her years in prison, having received a twenty-five-year sentence.”

***

1901 – Mrs. Stallion – Aurora, Missouri

Mrs. John Stallion and two sons by a former marriage murdered Alice Stallion, her step daughter, aged sixteen. The boys held Alice while her mother broke her skull with a poker. The body was then thrown in the James river.

***
 

At the instigation of his mother, Baroness De Courvigny, who was a drunk, Robert De Courvigny murdered his father. The wife had failed in poisoning her victim but the son succeeded in the task by means of a bullet.

***

Mother and 17-year old daughter; leaders of a large gang; daughter lured victims to the Tamarin home where they were robbed and murdered and cannibalized. 27 corpses were found.

***

1913 – Yates / Farris case – Troy, Tennessee

Mrs. Hennie Yates, thirty-six, and daughter, Floy Farris, fifteen, charged with the murder of Ligon Yates, twelve, and Ida May Yates, ten. They were the step-children of Hennie and the half-siblings of Floy. Children drowned in creek near home at Troy, Tenn.  Mrs. Yates will give no other reason for committing the crime than: “They made my life miserable.” The woman is apparently rational, realizes the enormity of her crime, but does not in any way show that she is remorseful. . The little girl cowered in a separate cell as far away from her mother as she could get. She declares she is afraid of her mother and assisted in the murder only after she had been threatened with death by her parent if she refused.

***

1919 – Broderick / Woodlock case –  St. Louis, Missouri

Ursula Broderick claimed she killed her father, Thomas P. Broderick, when she was 12. She was acquitted of murder by a jury who had believed her testimony that she had been protecting her mother from being beaten, and when 16, murdered her step-father, Joseph F. Woodlock, whom she falsely claimed has attempted to rape her. She was found guilty after three trials. Testimony revealed that Ursula had attempted to bribe a witness to perjure herself by repeating in court the false rape accusation story. After Ursula’s conviction, Mrs. Woodlock was charged with the murder of her both husbands, the state contending that Ursua had lied to protect her mother.

***


Ray Clough, 14, shot his father, James A. Clough, to death after his mother gave him the gun and instructed him to do the deed, falsely claiming the boy’s two younger brothers had just been murdered by the father.

***


Elizabeth Potegian, an Armenian immigrant living in central California, was accused of murdering her husband, two stepchildren. Mrs. Potegian under arrest, accused her mother, Mrs. Maria Torosian. When the police went to arrest the woman they found her body dangling from a rafter in her home. She had hanged herself. On the same day Mrs. Potegian tried to kill herself in her jail cell, slashing her wrists. During the investigation it was learned that while living in Armenia, Mrs. Torosian had been married six times, each husband meeting his death under mysterious circumstances. Mrs. Potegian was tried for the murder of her step-daughter, with her surviving son, Gordon, as the principal prosecution witness, and was found guilty.

***


1929 – Ethel LewisSt. Joseph, Michigan

Two demented mothers who murdered their five children confessed to killing their newborns. Mrs. Okal Gorham, 25, said the babies were poisoned or strangled to death by herself and her mother, Mrs. Ethel Lewis, 57. she could give no reason for the acts but said she and her mother frequently quarreled over family matters.

***


Landlady, a Hungarian immigrant took out insurance on her immigrant tenants and is suspected of many murders. Her son was implicated in pushing one of them from a window, witnessed by a man and a small girl, after poison failed to killed him.

***

1933 – Dorothy Irene Turley – St. John, Arizona

Mattie Turley, 15, shot her father in the back with a shotgun, having been encouraged by her mother, Mrs. Dorothea Irene Turley, who had convinced the daughter that the spirit world had required the act, having used a Ouija Board session to elicit the death order. Mattie understood, she declared, that “mother must be freed in order to marry the handsome cowboy.”

***


“I’ll buy you a car if you help me kill your Uncle Robert,” Mrs. May Carey, 52, told her sons Howard and James. They did it and – but not until eight years later – one of them got hanged along with their murder-coaching mom.

***


In prison since 1928, serving a long term for car theft which she committed with her son, Earl De Costa Mayer, a crime for which he also was also in prison, 73-year old, Mary (alias “Shoebox Annie” French) confessed to the murder of the car’s owner, plus three earlier murders, all four murders committed in league with her son. As soon as Mayer learned he was to be prosecuted for murder he committed suicide.

***


Chloe Davis, 11, was ordered by her mother, Lolita Davis – who had just seconds before beaten to death with a hammer the little girl’s siblings Daphne, 10, and Deborah, 7 – to beat her little brother Mark, 3, and the mother herself with the weapon. A coroner’s jury decided Mark died from his mother’s blows – not Chloe’s – and that Mrs. Davis died after slashing her own wrists.

***


During the trial of Leonarda Cianciulli for murdering three women in succession and cooking their body parts to make soap and desserts, the prosecution made an effort to prove that without assistance a woman could not overpower his victims, dismember the bodies and transport them. Leonarda, however, stood by her story that she committed the crimes alone and that her son, Joseph Pansardi,  had no involvement. A 2008 documentary film, La saponificatrice - Vita di Leonarda Cianciulli, argues that the murderess did indeed have Joseph as her accomplice and that Leonarda lied to protect him and was indeed successful in achieving that end.

***


Mrs. Gertrude Inez Brennan and two of her sons, Raymond, 23, and Robert, 16, killed 2 men she met through “lonely hearts club” letters. The men were shot in the head buried in a pigpen on the Brennan farm; later the bodies were dug up, burned and scattered on the city dump.

***


Asthmatic 16-year-old Sylvia Likens was tortured for months by her foster mother, her own children and neighborhood children, and eventually killed. She was beaten, had cigarettes put out on her skin, was forced to undress in the living room and insert an empty Coke bottle into private parts. After the beatings, Sylvia was forced into a scalding hot bath so she would be "cleansed of her sins." She was severely beaten and burned for wetting her mattress while asleep. She was thrown down the cellar stairs and locked in, given crackers for food and refused the right to use a bathroom. Gertrude Baniszewski announced to her children that Sylvia was a "prostitute, and she's proud of it; so we'll just put it on her stomach." She took a large needle and began to carve the words "I'm a prostitute and proud of it!" into Sylvia's stomach.

***

1972 – Carolyn Elizabeth McCrary – Santa Barbara, Ca. – Ginger McCrary Taylor, 22, daughter; Carolyn McCrary, 45.

“Mrs. McCrary is one in a family of five being questioned about a variety of crimes across the nation, including about 22 murders. Currently she is serving a nine-month sentence for harboring her son and husband in a supermarket robbery in Santa Barbara.”

***


It was a feminist murder – committed in the heyday of post-1960s women’s lib and involving four adult women and one 13-year-old girl, in a plot led by the wife of targeted optometrist John Bradford. The motive, as expressed by one of the killers, 18-year-old optometry assistant Joyce Cummings: “All we wanted was an all-female lab.” The pre-planned excuse was to be a concocted self-defense by a battered wife. The climax of the crime was when Priscilla Bradford ordered her daughter (from a previous marriage) to beat her bloodied, but still-alive, step-father with the iron skillet, the iconic feminist weapon, on the head.

***


In 1963 Theresa Jimmie Cross murdered the first of her three husbands. She was acquitted in a Sacramento, California court of murder on the basis of a fake self-defense claim. She married Robert Knorr, had four children with him and, in 1970, divorced him and undermined her children’s access to their father. She became increasingly abusive to the children, with constant beatings, escalating into tantrums in which she threw steak knives at them and put a gun to the head of her youngest child, Terry, threatening to kill her. Mom also stabbed and on another occasion shot Suesan, the bullet remaining in her body until the day before her murder. She forced her children to assist her in the brutal beatings of the chosen victim. When it came time to murder Suesan on June 16, 1984, she ordered the girl’s brothers William and Robert to burn their sister alive. Almost exactly a year later, on June 21, 1985, Sheila, whom her mother had forced to prostitute herself to raise cash for mom, died after having been beaten and tortured and locked in a closet for three days. It was not until 1993 that she was finally charged with the murders. To avoid the death penalty she pleaded guilty on October 17, 1995 and received a sentence of two consecutive life terms.

***

1995 – Mary Tene Steiner (Tene-Bimbo Gypsy Clan) – San Francisco, Ca. – Mother & daughter.

It was known to many the “Gypsy Sweetheart Scam,” by its many victims, all defrauded, but not all murdered. But between 1983 and 1995, after a group of five deaths came to be linked to a Gypsy family’s murder-for-profit scheme San Francisco police gave the name “Foxglove” to the case – after the suspected death tool, digitalis, a heart medicine derived from the foxglove flower. Six elderly men were apparently murdered soon after being married much younger women, all members of the Tene-Bimbo Gypsy clan, based in San Francisco. It is suspected each was killed through poisoning with digitalis (heart medication). Suspects arrested in the scam were Angela Tene Bufford; her mother, Mary Tene Steiner, of San Francisco, and, in New York, Sylvia Mitchell.

***

1996 – Anjanabai Gavit & daughters: Renuka Kiran Shinde, Seema Mohan GavitPune, Kolhapur & Nashik, Maharashtra, India – 

The family mother, 2 daughters and son-in-law kidnapped and murdered 9 infants and toddlers. The gang made ransom demands in some instances and used the children as props in petty thievery schemes. some victims were starved to death, others were murdered brutally by smashing them into telephone poles.

***

1996 – Ludmilla (Lyudmila) Spesivtsev – Novosibirsk, Siberia – Mother and son, cannibalism.

Lyudmila Spesivtseva, an employee of a Soviet government school, was sentenced to life in prison (or 13 years according to some accounts) for luring teenage girls for the pleasure of her son, Sasha, so that he could rape, torture and dismember them. The mother cooked the remains and served them up to her son. It is estimated that the number of teenage female victims numbers up to 80.

***


***

2000 – Lohstroh / Geisler case – Friendswood, Texas

A 10-year-old boy, who suffered from severe parental alienation induced by his mother, Deborah Geisler, of Texas, shot his father, Rick Lohstroh, with his mother’s gun in the back at the beginning of a parental “visitation.” Two years later his younger brother described the event: “When I was eight my DAD died ... I was scared! My mom told my brother to shot [sic] my DAD but my grandparents came to help me."

***

Li Huijie, from the central province of Henan, is accused of killing all four of her husbands in a two-year period on the orders of her mother, Tian Xueqin, for the "bride price" paid by rural grooms.

***


2003 – Judith Hawkey – Mark Center, Ohio

In 2003, Judith Hawkey's step-son, Corey Breninger shot and killed his father Robert Breninger at his Mark Center, Ohio, home. At the time, it was ruled an accident. The son revealed years later to a teacher after Hawkey had collected hundreds of thousands in life insurance from Robert. He said Hawkey had manipulated him to pull the trigger, and then lie about what happened.

***


A woman (name not disclosed)  and her two young adult sons murdered a neighbor then cooked and ate his body.

***

2005 – Shirin Gul – Kabul & Jalalabad, Afghanistan

Shirin Gul, her lover Rahmatullah, her 18-year-old son and four others murdered 27 men and robbed them in addition to killing her husband, the father of her son.

***

2010 – Eva Cummings – North Collins, New York

51-year-old Eva Cummings and her 31-year-old son, Luke Wright – mentally retarded and marginally functional – were charged in the death of the woman’s 23-year-old severely mentally disabled daughter who investigators said was repeatedly raped, beaten and scalded and had her face pushed into feces.

***


Silvia Meraz, leader of a small human sacrifice cult, comprising family members exclusively it would seem, was arrested, along with seven other family members, for the kidnapping, torture and murders of three persons, ritually sacrificed in 2009, 2010, 2012. Prosecutors say they believe the actual killings were done by Silvia and her son, Ramon.

***

2013 – Diane Staudte – Springfield, Missouri

This mother-daughter serial killer team engaged in a homicidal house-cleaning project using antifreeze, a deadly poison,  as their tool. The serial poisoner mom told detective that she chose to terminate the life of her husband Mark because she “hated him.” Her son Shawn deserved to die because he was “worse than a pest.” Daughter Sarah, who survived the attempt on her life, barely, was deemed not fit to live because she “would not get a job and had student loans that had to be paid.”

***

2013 – Inessa Tarverdiyeva – Stavropol region, Russia


A serial killer family: husband, sister & daughter as accomplices, with an estimated 30 or more victims.

***

Tuesday, April 29, 2014

Sante Kimes & Son: Serial Killer Team – USA 1998


3 Murder Victims:

1996 - Syed Bilal Ahmed, murdered by the mother & son together
Mar. 1998 - David Kazdin, murdered by son on orders of his mother
2000 - Irene Silverman, 82, murdered by the mother & son together

***

Wikipedia: Sante Kimes (born July 24, 1934) is an American felon who has been convicted of two murders, along with robbery, violation of anti-slavery laws, forgery and numerous other crimes. Many of these crimes were committed with assistance of her son Kenneth. The two of them were tried and convicted together for the murder of Irene Silverman, along with 117 other charges. The pair were also suspected but never charged in a third murder in the Bahamas, to which Kenneth has confessed.

According to court records, Kimes was born Sandra Louise Walker in Oklahoma City to a mother of partial Dutch descent and an East Indian father. Her estranged son, Kent Walker, in his book Son of a Grifter has reported from an old acquaintance of his mother that Sante Kimes was the daughter of a respectable family who was unable to cope with the young girl’s aberrant, wild antics; Kimes herself has claimed that her father was a laborer and that her mother was a prostitute who migrated from Oklahoma during the Dust Bowl to Los Angeles, where the young Kimes ran wild in the streets. But Sante Kimes has given numerous, conflicting stories about her origins and numerous other accounts are difficult to confirm, and thus Kent Walker says that his ancestry could be anything from Latino to East Indian to Indigenous American to simply white. She spent the better part of her life fleecing people of money, expensive merchandise, and real estate, either through elaborate con games, arson, forgery, or outright theft.

According to the book Son of a Grifter, she committed insurance fraud on numerous occasions, frequently by committing arson and then collecting for property damage. She delighted in introducing her husband as an ambassador - a ploy that even gained the couple access to a White House reception during the Ford administration. And she sometimes even impersonated Elizabeth Taylor, whom she resembled slightly. He also alleges that she committed many acts of fraud that were not even financially necessary, such as enslaving maids when she could easily afford to pay them and burning down houses she could have easily sold.

She frequently offered young, homeless illegal immigrants housing and employment, then kept them virtual prisoners by threatening to report them to the authorities if they didn’t follow her orders. As a result, she and her second husband, alcoholic motel tycoon Kenneth Kimes, spent years squandering his fortune on lawyers’ fees, defending themselves against charges of slavery. Kimes was eventually arrested in August 1985 and was sentenced by the U.S. District Court to five years in prison for violating federal anti-slavery laws. Her husband took a plea bargain and agreed to complete an alcohol treatment program; Ken, Sr. and their son, Kenny, lived a somewhat normal life until Sante was released from prison in 1989. Ken, Sr. died in 1994.

~ THE MURDERS ~

~ David Kazdin ~

David Kazdin had allowed Kimes to use his name on the deed of a home in Las Vegas that was actually occupied by Kenneth Sr. and Sante Kimes in the 1970s. Several years later, Sante Kimes convinced a notary to forge Kazdin’s signature on an application for a loan of $280,000, with the house as collateral. When Kazdin discovered the forgery and threatened to expose Kimes she ordered him killed. Kenneth Jr. murdered Kazdin by shooting him in the back of the head. According to another accomplice’s later testimony, all three participated in disposing of the evidence. Kazdin’s body was found in a dumpster near Los Angeles airport in March 1998. The murder weapon was never recovered, having been disassembled and dropped into a storm sewer.

~ Irene Silverman ~

In June 1998, with her son Kenny, Kimes perpetrated a scheme whereby she would assume the identity of their landlady, 82-year-old socialite Irene Silverman, and then appropriate ownership of her $7.7 million Manhattan mansion. Despite the fact Silverman’s body was never found, both mother and son were convicted of murder in 2000, in no small part because of the discovery of Kimes’ notebooks detailing the crime and notes written by Silverman, who was extremely suspicious of the pair. During the trial for the Kadzin murder Kenneth Kimes confessed that after his mother had used a stun gun on Silverman, he strangled her, stuffed her corpse into a bag and deposited it in a dumpster in Hoboken, New Jersey.

~ Sayed Bilal Ahmed ~

Kenneth also confessed to murdering a third man, banker Sayed Bilal Ahmed, at his mother’s behest in The Bahamas in 1996, which had been suspected by Bahamian authorities at the time. Kenneth testified that the two acted together to drug Ahmed, drown him in a bathtub, and dump his body offshore, but no charges were ever filed in that case. Sante Kimes denies any involvement or knowledge of the murders, and claims that Kenneth’s confession was solely to avoid the death penalty.

~ Trials ~

Although the Kazdin murder happened first, The Kimes’ were apprehended in New York City and tried first for the Silverman murder. Evidence recovered from their car helped establish the case for trying them on Kazdin’s murder as well.

The Silverman trial was unusual in many aspects, namely the rare combination of a mother/son team and the fact that no body was recovered. Nonetheless, the jury was unanimous in voting to convict them of not only murder but 117 other charges including robbery, burglary, conspiracy, grand larceny, illegal weapons possession, forgery and eavesdropping on their first poll on the subject. The judge also took the unusual step of ordering Kimes not to speak to the media even after the jury had been sequestered as a result of her passing a note to New York Times reporter David Rhode in court. The judge threatened to have Kimes handcuffed during further court appearances if she persisted and restricted her telephone access to calls to her lawyers. The judge contended that Kimes was attempting to influence the jury as they may have seen or heard any such interviews, and that there would be no cross-examination as there would be in court. Kimes had earlier chosen to not take the stand in her own defense after the judge ruled that prosecutors could question her about the previous conviction on slavery charges.

During the sentencing portion of the Silverman trial, Sante Kimes made a prolonged statement to the court blaming the authorities, including their own lawyers, for framing them. She went on to compare their trial to the Salem Witch Trials and claim the prosecutors were guilty of “murdering the Constitution” before the judge told her to be quiet. When the statement was concluded the presiding judge responded that Mrs Kimes was a sociopath and a degenerate and her son was a dupe and “remorseless predator” before imposing the maximum sentence on both of them.

In October 2000, while doing an interview, Kenneth held Court TV reporter Maria Zone hostage by pressing a ballpoint pen into her throat. Zone had interviewed Kimes once before without incident. Kenneth Kimes’ demand was that his mother not be extradited to California, where the two faced the death penalty for the murder of David Kazdin. After four hours of negotiation Kimes removed the pen from Zone’s throat. Negotiators created a distraction which allowed them to quickly remove Zone and wrestle Kimes to the ground.

In March 2001, Kenneth Kimes was extradited to Los Angeles to stand trial for the murder of David Kazdin. Sante Kimes was extradited to Los Angeles in June 2001. During that trial in June 2004, while he was facing the death penalty, Kenneth changed his plea from “not guilty” to “guilty” and implicated his mother in the murder in exchange for a plea deal that his mother not receive the death penalty if convicted. Sante Kimes again made a prolonged statement denying the murders and accusing police and prosecutors of various kinds of misconduct, and was again eventually ordered by the presiding judge to be silent. The sentencing judge in the Kazdin case called Mrs. Kimes “one of the most evil individuals” she had met in her time as a judge.

~ Imprisonment ~

Sante Kimes is currently serving a sentence of 120 years at the Bedford Hills Correctional Facility for Women in New York. On her prisoner papers, Sante’s projected release date is on March 3, 2119. Additionally, Kimes and her son were each sentenced to life for the death of David Kazdin in California. Kenneth Kimes is currently incarcerated at Richard J. Donovan Correctional Facility in California.

~ In media ~

A 2001 made-for-TV movie, Like Mother, Like Son: The Strange Story of Sante and Kenny Kimes, starred Mary Tyler Moore as Sante Kimes, Gabriel Olds as Kenny, and Jean Stapleton as Silverman. In 2006, another television movie based on a book about the case, A Little Thing Called Murder, starring Judy Davis and Jonathan Jackson, aired on Lifetime. She was also featured in a 2008 episode of the television show Dateline.

***


***


***


***



***


For similar cases, see Murder-Coaching Moms

***

Tuesday, September 3, 2013

Elizabeth & Mary Branch: English Serial Killers - 1740


4 DEATHS attributed:

Jane Butterworth, Servant girl 13
Another Servant girl
Benjamin Branch - Elizabeth’s husband
Mrs. Branch – Elizabeth’s mother

***

EXCERPT (Article 1 of 3): Elizabeth, aged 67, and her daughter Mary, 24, were both charged with the cruel murder of their maid, Jane Butterworth. A transcript of their trial, which took place at Taunton, Somerset, in March 1740, reported that:

It was obvious, judging by the suspicions of their neighbours, that both the accused had also committed other murders in the past. Mrs Branch’s husband died under circumstances that led others who lived nearby to believe she had poisoned him and they were convinced that she had hanged her mother, after murdering her, to avoid an investigation into the cause of the death. Human bones were also discovered in a well near her [Elizabeth’s] farm, which were believed to be those of one of her servant girls who disappeared and was never heard from again.

With such a reputation Mrs Branch found it difficult to get female staff in the locality and when she was in need of one she went further afield and brought Jane Butterfield from Bristol. The young girl was hardly in the house before the two women subjected her to a brutal regime, and eventually beat her so Elizabeth Branch and her Daughter Beating their Victim savagely that she died. The older woman had Jane’s corpse buried secretly in the graveyard and might have escaped blame, in spite of the complaint of her other maid, who had witnessed the murder and had been forced to lie next to her in bed, if a strange light had not been seen over the girl’s grave, by several persons. This unearthly manifestation confirmed the neighbours’ suspicions, and when the body was secretly removed at night, it was found by Mr Salmon, a surgeon, to be covered with wounds and other marks of violence.

When the case was first called, it was discovered that Mrs Branch had bribed some of the jurors, and there was some delay before they could be replaced. The trial lasted over six hours, and after a short consultation the jury brought in a verdict of guilty. It was noticed that Mrs Branch’s expression remained unchanged at their findings, but several times kicked Mary Vigor, one of the prosecution witnesses, as she stood by her at the bar while she was giving evidence. When sentence was passed the next day, the condemned elder woman complained bitterly to the court about the illegality of changing the jury, exclaiming that if she and her daughter had been tried by the first jury, they would not have been convicted.

[Geoffrey Abbott, Amazing Stories of Female Executions, 2006, Summersdale Publishers
(First published as Lipstick on the Noose’ in 2003), p. 33 ff. of 2006 edition]

***

EXCERPT (Article 2 of 3): Former servants and neighbours all gave evidence of the torture they inflicted on their servants, including a boy who was forced to eat his own excrement. In this case the medical report stated that Butterworth was whipped until the flesh on her fingers was stripped away and tendons were exposed. [University of Cambridge]

***

FROM Wikipedia (Article 3 of 3): Elizabeth Branch (1672–1740) –  Elizabeth Parry was born either in Bristol or Norton St Philip in Somerset. Her father was a well-off ship's surgeon, from whom she received a £2,000 dowry upon her marriage to Benjamin Branch, a gentleman farmer. Elizabeth quickly gained a reputation for violence. She and her daughter, Betty Branch, would torture small animals, apparently taking inspiration from stories of Nero. They would often beat and humiliate their servants, especially after the death of Benjamin in 1730, so that soon no local persons were willing to serve them.

On 13 February 1740, as witnessed by Anne James, the dairymaid, Elizabeth sent her 13-year-old serving maid Jane Buttersworth on an errand to a nearby farm. On her return, Elizabeth and Betty, irate at how long she had taken, beat her for almost seven hours until she died. They buried her secretly, but enough suspicion was aroused that her body was exhumed and examined, whereupon the wounds were found. Elizabeth and Betty were tried for murder on March 31 at the Somerset assizes. The jury returned a guilty verdict without retiring to deliberate, and the two women were hanged at Ilchester on May 3.

***


***


For more cases, see: Women Who Like to Torture

***


For similar cases, see Murder-Coaching Moms

***