FULL TEXT (Article 1 of 4): Greenville, Texas. – Mrs. Velma
Patterson, 34, of Commerce, was charged with murder Friday in the death of her
11-year-old daughter, Billie Fae McCausland.
The Hunt county grand jury returned the indictment Friday
after Dr. Landon C. Moore, Dallas chemist, reported to District Attorney Henry
Pharr that more than a lethal quantity of a poison was found in the child’s
viscera.
Billie Fae’s body was exhumed from the little Pleasant Grove
cemetery near Commerce Monday and the organs sent to Dallas on a magistrate’s
orders and upon recommendation of a grand jury.
~ First Thought Flu
The indictment climaxed several days of investigation of the
child’s death which occurred last January 7 at Commerce after a three-day
illness. At that time, death was attributed to intestinal influenza.
Mrs. Patterson has been held in the Hunt county jail here
since the investigation started. Deputy Sheriff V. L. Delaney said Friday
afternoon that a search of the jail cell where she is confined had revealed a
bottle of poison, a razor blade, and several letters in which she gave
instructions for disposition of her body in the event of death, and also
instructions for the care of a 15-year-old son.
Bill Patterson, husband of the accused woman, died several
months ago.
~ Quick Trial Seen
District Attorney Pharr said Mrs. Patterson’s trial probably
would be set for the present term of Eighth District Court.
The child’s body was exhumed from the quiet rural cemetery
near commerce before a group of county officials headed by Pharr and Sheriff D.
M. Newton, who brought the viscera to Dallas for examination.
[“11-Year-Old Tot Slain; Murder Charges Filed Against Mother
In Greenville; Poison Is Discovered,” Valley Morning Star (Harlingen, Tx.),
Mar. 21, 1936, p. 8]
***
***
FULL TEXT (Article 2 of 4): Greenville, April 30: — The
latest love affair of Mrs. Velma Patterson, already hinted as a possible motive
for the alleged poisoning of her little daughter, Dorothy, was mentioned again
today as the state closed its murder case against the thrice-married brunette.
The prosecution wound up its case at 11.10 a. m. and Judge
Charles Berry recessed court until afternoon, when the defense will begin its
efforts to break down the circumstantial evidence presented against the woman.
In closing testimony, Fred Patterson of Commerce, brother of
Mrs. Patterson’s third husband, Bill, said that after ‘the death of Dorothy
McCasland, 12, Mrs. Patterson told him she was in love with Jimmy Wallace, Lone
Oak cattleman.
Fred Patterson quoted the woman as saying she was “thinking
of marrying him (Wallace).
“I wonder what my family would think about it?” the witness
said Mrs. Patterson asked him.
Annie Cooper, maid in the Patterson home at Commerce,
previously had revealed that Mrs. Patterson was “deeply in love” with Wallace
and had said she “would marry him if it wasn’t for the children.”
~ Two Children Died.
At that time her two children; Dorothy and Billie Fae
McCasland, were living. They died early this year and the state claims poison
administered by the mother was responsible Fred Patterson said he visited his
sister-in-law’s home several times from Jan. 4 to 17 and saw Wallace there
“frequently; often before they ate breakfast.”
Bill Patterson, the woman’s third husband, died the latter
part of last year. Previously she had married and divorced W. W. McCasland, the
father of Dorothy and Billie Fae, and Bill Kelly.
McCasland told today how Billie Fae, who died last Jan. 7,
struggled for breath and. In convulsions, begged him to take her where she
could get fresh air. He said she died in his arms while he was holding her In
his arms, after carrying her to a back porch.
“She died before I could get her back to the bedroom,” he
testified.
“I went to Mrs. Patterson’s Sunday, Jan. 5, to see the
children and Billle Fae was sick. She asked me never to leave her. She was
cramping, begging for water and asking for a doctor.
“The next day I left to sell a load of wood and Mrs.
Patterson asked me to stop In town and bring her groceries^ and a poison to
kill rats. I returned and never stopped the motor truck, left the articles and
went on.
~ Brother-in-law On Stand.
“The truck bogged down and I had to turn back. When I
returned to the Pattersons, Billie Fae was terribly sick and died three hours
later.”
Over defense protests, Judge Berry yesterday permitted the
admission of testimony concerning Billie Fae’s death. Mrs. Patterson is on
trial for the death of Dorothy, but also is under indictment for murder, In the
death of Billie Fae, also allegedly a poison victim.
The defense attempted to get McCasland to admit he was drunk
the day before Dorothy died and the day she was burled, but he denied being
intoxicated. He also denied giving to Annie Cooper, maid in the Patterson home
then, part of a bottle of whisky.
Mrs. W. M. Mattingly of Commerce, a nurse, testified she
attended Dorothy Friday night, Feb. 14, before. the child died the following
Monday.
“I saw no medicine on the place but Mrs. Patterson told me
she had given medicine and would continued to do so,” Mrs. Mattingly said.
~ Testifies to Exhumation Order
The practical nurse said she left the next morning (Feb. 15)
and didn’t return until the child died; then to “sit up with the corpse.”
Justice of the Peace J. A. wyatt of Hopkins county testified
concerning entering an order in his inquest book for exhumation of the body of
Billie Fae March 16.
The last witness before the state rested was Mrs. Fred Patterson,
who testified:
“Velma told me she was crazy about Jimmy Wallace and they
were going to get married if they could.”
Defense Attorney Harris didn’t reveal which witnesses ho
would call first. It was considered likely Mrs. Patterson would testify near
the end of the defense case.
Through it all Mrs. Patterson sat quietly, her face as
expressionless as it had been all through presentation of the state’s case,
except when her former maid, Annie Cooper, had created a sensation by revealing
the defendant was in love with Jimmie Wallace, a cattleman, and allegedly said
she “would marry him. if it wasn’t for the children.”
Then, as her purported love affair was unfolded in the words
of the maid, Mrs. Patterson leaned forward, listening intently to every word.
[“State Rests Case In Murder Trial Of Greenville Woman –
Latest Love Affair Of Mrs. Velma Patterson Is Mentioned Again,” Corsicana Daily
Sun (Tx.), Apr. 30, 1936, p. 1]
***
FULL TEXT (Article 3 of 4): Greenville, Texas, May 3. – Mrs.
Velma Patterson, 34-year-old brunettw widow, was acquitted by a district court
jury today on a charge that she had killed her daughter, Dorothy MacCasland,
12, by poisoning. Mrs. Patterson, who is also charged with murder in the death
of another daughter, Billie Fae McCausland, shouted with joy as the jury
verdict was announced.
Her mother, Mrs. L. W. Williams, who was at her side, also
was overcome with happiness. Mrs. Patterson ran to the jury box and shook hands
with the jurors after the verdict was returned.
The jury of twelve farmers had deliberated since 4:55 p. m.
yesterday. The verdict was brought in at 3 p. m.
Mrs. Patterson was returned to her cell in the Hunt county
jail after receiving congratulations of friends and relatives. She was smiling
and speaking animatedly in sharp contrast to her downcast demeanor of yesterday
when District Attorney Henry Pharr wound up his arguments before the jury by
demanding the death penalty. At that time she broke down completely and sobbed
audibly.
~ Future Plans Unknown.
Pharr was out of the city and there was no indication from
the state as to whether the other charge against Mrs. Patterson would be
pressed. Her local attorney, H. L. Carpenter, expressed the opinion that it
would not, but was not ready to say what efforts would be made to release her
from jail pending a decision. Mrs. Patterson said she would insist that her
attorneys attempt to obtain her release on bond tomorrow. She was confident she
would be freed.
“I will insist that my attorneys make every effort to obtain
my release on bond tomorrow,” she said. “When I get out I will take my son
(Junior McCasland) and go to the home of my sister, Mrs. Clara Purcelle, in El
Paso for a long rest.”
Mrs. Patterson bitterly referred to witnesses who testified
against her.
“The jury gave me acquittal but it didn’t give me back what
I wanted most – that’s my babies. I loved them and lived for them. I wanted to
rear them and make something of them.”
~ Only Four Ballots.
The jury, it was reported, stood 7 to 5 for acquittal on
three ballots and returned its verdict on the fourth.
Mrs. Patterson has been in jail here since the bodies of the
two children, who died early this year, were disinterred from the quiet little
Pleasant Grove cemetery near Commerce last month. Death certificates of both
Billie Fae and Dorothy stated that they had died of intestinal influenza, but
the state contended that poison had been fatal to both. To support this claim,
Dr. Landon G. Moore of Dallas testified as a state witness that he had found
poison in the viscera of both children. He examined the viscera after the
bodies were exhumed on recommendation of the grand jury.
The defense countered with withesses who testified that deep
devotion existed between the mother and the daughter she was accused of
poisoning. Mrs. Williams testified that under Mrs. Patterson’s encouragement
the child professed religion last summer, joined the church and attended Sunday
school. Mrs. Joe Stone, Commerce beauty shop operator, said Mrs. Patterson’s
treatment of Dorothy was that of “devotion and outstanding love.” Several other
witnesses declared that the mother was kind and affectionate toward the child.
The state also had offered testimony that the comely,
thrice-married Mrs. Patterson was in love with a cattleman and wanted to marry
him “if it wasn’t for the children.” The defense answered that the mother loved
her children and had cried “oh, I wish it had been me” when Dorothy died.”
[“Jury Decides East Texas Woman Not Guilty of Murder - Mrs.
Velma Patterson Exonerated in Alleged Poison Death of Her 12-Year-Old Daughter;
Plans to Seek Immediate Release From Greenville Jail and Go to El Paso for Long
Rest,” The Shreveport Times (La.), May 4, 1936, p. 11]
***
FULL TEXT (Article 4 of 4): Greenville, Texas, Nov. 18 –
Illness of the principal state witness caused postponement today of the second
trial of Mrs. Velma Patterson. Attractive widow of Commerce, Texas, who is
accused of poisoning her two small daughters so that they would not interfere
with her proposed marriage.
Mrs. Patterson was scheduled to go on trial today on charges
of giving arsenic to her 11-year-old daughter, Billie Fae McCasland. She
acquitted May 3 on charges in connection until next term of court when Dr.
Landon C. Moore, Dallas chemist who examined Billie Fae’s body, was sick and
unable to come to Greenville.
[“Postpone Poison Trial Monday At Greenville, Texas,” The
Shreveport Times (La.), Nov. 17, 1936, p. 18]
***
[“Jury Decides East Texas Woman Not Guilty of Murder - Mrs.
Velma Patterson Exonerated in Alleged Poison Death of Her 12-Year-Old Daughter;
Plans to Seek Immediate Release From Greenville Jail and Go to El Paso for Long
Rest,” The Shreveport Times (La.), May 4, 1936, p. 11]
***
NOTE: No reports have been discovered of the second trial,
for the murder of Billie Fae. Presumably the prosecution quit the case. No
charges were brought for the death of her husband. Bill Patterson, and no
reports of an exhumation of his remains have been located as of this writing.
***
Her
acquittal still did not exonerate Patterson in the public’s eye. “Everyone thought Velma
was guilty,” Conrad said. (Dr. James Conrad, Texas A&M University-Commerce,
Archivist)
[Chance A. Crane, “Velma Patterson – Mommie Dearest or Mother
Superior?” In My Head, Sep. 13, 2010]
***
***
***
***
***
***
***
***
