James Joseph Richardson served 21 years in prison for the murder of one of his seven children and step-children who met their death following a meal laced with parathion, with a pesticide. A courageous lawyer, Mark Lane, believed him innocent and due to his tireless efforts won his freedom. Crucial exculpatory evidence had been unlawfully withheld by the prosecution and sheriff from the defense during the murder trial. Richardson was the first person to benefit from a Florida law which provides reparations for the wrongly convicted.
It is believed that the woman nicknamed “Big Mama,” who was baby-sitting the kids, aged 2 through 8, and prepared their deadly lunch, was the perpetrator. At the time of the deaths Bessie Reese was on parole from prison where she had been doing time for murdering her second husband. She was also suspected of murdering her first husband following a meal she had prepared.
While in a nursing home Besse Resse had repeatedly told attendants that she had indeed been the killer (unless one were to opine, like the sheriff who supported the prosecution of Richardson, that Besse she merely felt guilt for serving up food she had known was poisoned). Her exact words in one of these instances were:
“I did it. Lord forgive me,”
The quotation can be found in the following article: Charles Whited, “How can innocent victim ever be repaid?” The Spokesman-Review (Wa.), Apr. 28, 1989, p. B-8
There is a great deal of material online on this case. One of the better examples reviews the book on the case published before Richardson’s exoneration::
Hans Sherrer, "Arcadia and the Twenty Year Effort to Exonerate James Joseph Richardson," for Justice: Denied magazine, " Dec. 2008.
Dec. 26, 1935 – birth of Besse Reese
circa 1952 – death of Besse’s first husband dies after eating beef stew
1955 – Besse murders of husband, by gunshot, on her birthday
circa 1960 – Besse paroled
Oct 25, 1967 – poisoning of the 7 Richardson children
May 27, 1968 – trial of Richardson, 31, at Lee County courthouse; murder of betty Bryant, step-daughter
May 31, 1968 – found guilty, with death penalty recommended
1970 – Lane’s book, Arcadia, published
1972 – US Supreme Court ruling resulted to resentencing to 25 years life in prison
1986 – nursing home confessions are publicly exposed
Aug. 1988 – Lane launched a “Free James Richardson” campaign by staging a rally in Arcadia
May 5, 1989 – Richardson’s murder charge was dismissed
For similar cases see: Baby-Sitter Serial Killers
For links to other cases of woman who murdered 2 or more husbands (or paramours), see Black Widow Serial Killers.
More cases, see: Female Serial Killers of Africa & the African Diaspora